Healthcare-v2009 SSpc55: Bird collision deterrence


    Excerpted from LEED 2009 for Healthcare

    SS Pilot Credit 55: Bird collision deterrence


    Reduce bird injury and mortality from in-flight collisions with buildings.


    Comply with the “Building façade and site structures,” “Exterior lighting,” and “Performance monitoring plan” requirements below.

    Building façade and site structures

    Develop a building façade and site design strategy to make the building and site structures visible as physical barriers to birds.

    If all materials on the building façade have a Threat Factor of 15 or below, the project is exempt from the building façade requirements and the following Bird Collision Threat Rating calculations are not required. If any material on the building façade has a Threat Factor above 15, then the Bird Collision Threat Factor Rating calculations are required.

    All other structures on the site, including, but not limited to handrails, guardrails, windscreens, noise barriers, gazebos, pool safety fencing, bus shelters, band shells, etc. must be constructed entirely of materials with a threat score value of 15 or less.

    Steps for calculating the Bird Collision Threat Rating (BCTR)

    First separate each building facade into Façade Zone 1 and Façade Zone 2. Façade Zone 1 includes the first 36 feet above grade, measured from grade at all points, as well as 12 feet above any green roof. Façade Zone 2 includes all façade areas above 36 feet. Establish total areas for Façade Zone 1, Façade Zone 2 and for the Adjusted Building Façade Area. Then identify the Material Types present on each façade, the corresponding Threat Factor of each material (for detailed types and associated threat factors, see the Bird Collision Deterrence Material Threat Factors developed by the American Bird Conservancy), and the total area of each Material Type. Lastly, establish the Factored Area for each Zone.

    No more than 15% of the facade area in Façade Zone 1 can have a Threat Factor higher than 75. This area is quantified separately as the Hazardous Glazing FactorThe ratio of interior illuminance at a given point on a given plane (usually the work plane) to the exterior illuminance under known overcast sky conditions. LEED uses a simplified approach for its credit compliance calculations. The variables used to determine the daylight factor include the floor area, window area, window geometry, visible transmittance (Tvis) and window height. (HGF) in the calculator. However, more than 15% of the glazed area in Zone 2 may have a Factor higher than 75. All glazed corners or fly-through conditions must have a Threat Factor less than or equal to 25.

    Table 1: General material types: threat potential

    Material Type
    Greatest Threat Potential Glass: Highly reflective and/ or completely transparent surface
    Glass: Reflective or transparent surface interrupted by a visible pattern based on the 2 x 4 Rule*.
    Glass: Reflective or transparent surface shielded by screens, shutters, or louvers where the resultant exposed glass satisfies the 2 x 4 Rule*.
    Glass: Translucent with matte or textured surface
    Least Threat Potential Opaque surface
    *The 2 x 4 Rule is defined as a collision deterrence module based upon the physical profile of a bird in flight. Current research has established maximum module dimensions of 2” high x 4” wide.

    Using the formulas below, achieve a maximum total building Bird Collision Threat Rating (BCTR) of 15 or less. The Bird Collision Threat Rating Calculation Spreadsheet can also be used.

    For each Façade Zone, calculate the Factored Area:

    [(Material Type 1 Threat Factor) x (Material Type Area)] + [(Material Type 2 Threat Factor) x (Material Type Area)]… = Façade Zone Factored Area

    Determine the Adjusted Building Façade Area:

    [(2 x Zone 1 Area) + Zone 2 Area] = Adjusted Building Façade Area

    Calculate the total building Bird Collision Threat Rating by dividing the sum of Zone 1 and Zone 2 Factored Areas by the Adjusted Building Façade Area:

    (Zone 1 Factored Area + Zone 2 Factored Area) / Adjusted Building Façade Area = Total Building BCTR


    Exterior lighting

    Exterior building fixtures that are not necessary for safety, building entrances, and circulation shall be automatically shut off from midnight until 6 a.m. Manual override capability may be provided for occasional after-hours use.

    In addition, meet these requirements for all exterior luminaires located inside the project boundary (except those listed under “Exemptions”), based on the following:

    • The photometric characteristics of each luminaire when mounted in the same orientation and tilt as specified in the project design; and
    • The lighting zone of the project property (at the time construction begins). Classify the project under one lighting zone using the lighting zones definitions provided in the Illuminating Engineering Society and International Dark Sky Association (IES/IDA) Model Lighting Ordinance (MLO) User Guide.

    Do not exceed the following luminaire uplight ratings, based on the specific light source installed in the luminaire, as defined in IES TM-15-11, Addendum A.

    Table 2. Maximum uplight ratings for luminaires

    MLO lighting zone Luminaire uplight rating
    LZ0 U0
    LZ1 U1
    LZ2 U2
    LZ3 U3
    LZ4 U4

    Exemptions from the exterior lighting requirements

    The following exterior lighting is exempt from the requirements, provided it is controlled separately from the nonexempt lighting:

    • specialized signal, directional, and marker lighting for transportation;
    • government-mandated roadway lighting;
    • hospital emergency departments, including associated helipads; and
    • lighting for the national flag in MLO lighting zones 2, 3, or 4.


    Performance monitoring plan

    Develop a three-year post-construction monitoring plan to routinely monitor the effectiveness of the building and site design in preventing bird collisions. Include methods to identify and document locations where repeated bird strikes occur, the number of collisions, the date, the approximate time, and features that may be contributing to collisions. List potential design solutions and provide a process for voluntary corrective action.

    General Pilot Documentation Requirements

    Register for the pilot credit

    Credits 1-14

    Credits 15-27

    Credits 28-42

    Credits 43-56

    Credits 57-67

    Credits 68-82

    Credits 83-103

    Credit Specific: BD+C

    Building façade and site features

    • For materials on the building and site with a Threat Factor of 15 or below, submit a narrative describing why the materials, and building in general, are “bird-friendly.” Include a material list and supporting data.
    • A completed Bird Collision Threat Rating spreadsheet
    • Plan(s) and/or elevation(s) depicting the location of all materials and shading/screening devices used to comply with this credit
    • Applicable specification details on all materials and shading/screening devices used to comply with this credit. If a chosen material does not have a Threat Factor value, provide an estimated value with justification.
    • A narrative or statement acknowledging that both surface reflection and visibility of any surface 3 frit patterns have been taken into account.

    Exterior lighting

    • Site lighting plan with boundaries, elements, location of fixtures, lighting zone, and applicable measurements
    • Luminaire schedule showing uplight ratings, nighttime off-time durations for a typical day, and manual override capability

    Performance monitoring plan

    • A copy of the post-construction monitoring plan
    • 11/22/2016:

      Edited the Credit Specific: BD+C submittals.

      • 10/16/2015:

        Expanded the applicability to all rating systems

        Added site features (site structures with glass) to the credit

        Adjusted and simplified the “Bird Collision Threat Rating” calculation

        Simplified the lighting requirements

        Adjusted the documentation based on the above changes to Requirements

        Miscellaneous edits to the background information, for reference


Start a new comment thread

Aug 18 2017
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.

Copyright 2017 – BuildingGreen, Inc.